In Beautiful downtown Bucyrus. OH
301 S. Sandusky (419) 689-0208

Office Hours

Monday - by appointment 

Tuesday- by appointment 

Wednesday- 10am-5pm

Thursday  - 10am-5pm

Friday - 10am-5pm

Sat. 10-1

About Us

Our Mission Statement

At Castle Auctions and Appraisals, we believe clients deserve professional and ethical representation, discretion, extraordinary service and a knowledgeable guide to navigate the auction process. Our relationships with the communities we serve is built on trust and integrity. Our team is dedicated to providing the highest quality service and exceeding our clients’ expectations. 

Our Values

Our Faith, which gives us hope. 

Our Family, who give us purpose. 

Our Integrity, which is who we are. 

Our Business, which provides for us. 

Our Community, whom we serve. 

Follow us on Facebook

Like us on Facebook  

Click the link below


2019 Bratwurst Festival Stein Auction

 2019 Bratwurst Festival Stein Auction 

Schines Art Park @ 8pm 

This year Castle Auctions and Appraisals is proud and honored to conduct the stein auction. 

The 2019  Stein Auction will once again benefit the Bratwurst Festival Royalty Program. 

Steins, Including the #1 Stein: #1 Button, #1 mini-stein, a 29 x 55 wooden flag made by Andrew Rush valued at $2,300 (shown here) and more! 

This years Stein "Salutes our Veterans"

Link to Bratwurst Festival Details

Gold Jewelry Coins Toys Dolls Tools Furniture


Saturday, Aug. 24 2019 

 9:00 A.M. 

Richland County Fairgrounds 

750 Home Rd. 

Mansfield Ohio 44906 

Jewelry:  50+ pcs 10K & 14K Gold Rings, 14K Gold watches, 10K & 14K Earrings,  Beautiful collection of genuine vintage sterling silver turquoise pcs, lots of Costume Jewelry including bakelite, borealis, glass, real stones. Weiss, Eisenberg, Whiting and Davis, Trifari, Vendome, VanDell, BSK, Craft, Gerry, Emons, Monet, Sarah Coventry, Coro, Celebrity, Gerry, EMJ, more

Coins: 1909S Indian Head Cent, 25+/- Silver Dollars, Silver Halves, Quarters & Dimes....

Silver Eagles, Currency, Some Silver Proof Sets, A lot of not silver Proof Sets. 

Sterling Silver Flatware Set

Furniture and Household:  4 Poster Twin Bed, 3 queen size beds, Lamps, Smoking Cabinet, Art, Sitting Chairs, Dressers, Chests of drawers, Mirrors, 2 vintage Secretary desks, Singer sewing machine in Cabinet, Wrought Iron Bed Frame, Sofa, Drop Leaf Table Cart, Rocking Chairs, Cast Iron Skillets, Crocks, End stands, coffee tables, 2 piece cupboard, Room divider, oil lamps, Tea tray table, Marble top table,  Chest, Console stereo, Buffet, Bench, Dorm size refrigerator, child sized rocker, wooden crates, Drafting table, Large framed chalkboard, jewelry armoire, daybed, corner curio cabinet, night stands, footstools, computer desk

Tools, Lawn & Garden: Machinist tools (incl. Starrett, Luftkin & Mitutoyo) Toro S620 Snow Blower, shovels, rakes, gas cans, wheel barrow, license plates, pulleys, push mowers, antique tool box, 

Toys: Cast Iron Toys,  Horse shoes,  vintage sled, Vintage Mickey Mouse etc.

Collectibles: WWI Military smalls,  Nice Fenton, Carnival glass, Cranberry, Vinyl Records, Beautiful Quilts, 2 Spinning Wheels, Ironstone China, Buttons & Vintage sewing spools, Cast iron cobblers and stands, Copper Boiler,  Butter churn, boxes of miniature alcohol bottles, Bissell antique floor sweeper, Fancy vintage hats

     Doll Collection:

Presbyterian Dolls made in Bucyrus Ohio.

  Madame Alexander

Madame                                   Jeanne walker                                 McGuffy Ana

Lucinda                                   Cinderella                                         Poor Cinderella

Fairy God Mother                   Marme-Little Women                       Laurie-Little Women

Amy-Little Women                 Beth-Little Women                           Jo-Little Women

Meg                                          Scarlett O'Hara                                 Rhett & Scarlett

Rebecca                                   Sleeping Beauty                              Renoir

Snow White                              Degas                                               Bride's Maid of Honor


Huckleberry Finn            Mark Twain           Becky Thatcher

Tom Sawyer                  Snow White           Faith Wick

Hansel & Gretel             Jack & Jill          Mother Goose

Geni                        Pinocchio            Old King Cole

Hans Brinker                Polly Anna           Straw Man

Cowardly Lion               Tin Man              Dorothy

Miss United States          Laurel               Diamond Jubilee

Lillian Russell             Mae West             Abe Lincoln

George Washington           Liberace             Jackie Gleason

Art Carney                  Mary Mary quite Contrary   Molly

 Precious Moments, Bradley, Ideal, Gorham, Hallmark, Heaveny Doll, Presbyterian dolls, Sasha, Kewpie, Jesco, Horsman, Reeves International, Heritage, World, 

Abbott & Costello                Shirley Temple          Little Miss Muffett

Rupunzel                               Pouty Patty               Little Debbie

Kewpie                                  Poor Pitiful Pearl      Martha Washington

Marilyn Monroe         Fred Astaire      Ginger Rogers

Emmett Kelly    

Check back for additional details

Missie K. Striker, "Your Friendly Auctioneer"

Amanda J. Paez, Auctioneer

Becca Hostetler, Apprentice Auctioneer

Mark Twain Frazier, Apprentice Auctioneer

Food service available.

We accept Cash, Check Debit and Credit. 

Sports Memorabilia Auction


Sunday Aug. 25th 2019 @ 4:00pm Richland County Fairgrounds

 Sunday Aug. 25th 2019  @ 4:00pm

Richland County Fairgrounds 

750 Home Rd. 

Mansfield Ohio 44906   

 Sports Memorabilia Collection  

Vintage Bobble Heads, Custom Artwork, Signed Baseball Bats, Signed Baseballs, Autographed Baseball Cards, thousands of Baseball cards from the 30's, 40's, 50's, 60's, 70's, 80's, & 90's. 

Artwork to include:

Custom Commissioned Fred Dingle Painting of Bob Feller and Omar Vizquel 28" X 32"

Mickey Mantle Subway Poster Framed 60" X 43" 

 "The First Pitch" Jacob's Field 1994 Large Framed Print

Mark Mcguire 35/70 Framed 28"X 23" Lithograph by Danny Day

Joe Dimaggio 205/388 Autographed Danny Day Print 

World Series Braves/Indians Municipal Stadium circa 1948

1995 Indians "Going, Going, Gone" Bob Leather Print, Framed

Bob Feller Autographed Photo

Vintage Bobble Heads including:

1960's Detroit Tiger Bobblehead in original box.

1967 Mr. Reds Bobblehead

1967 Kansas City Chiefs Bobblehead

1967 Houston Oilers Bobblehead

1967 Baltimore Colts Bobblehead

1967 Cincinnati Bengals Bobblehead

Johnny Bench Bobbleheads #1, #2, #3,, #4, & #5.

Adam Dunn Pepsi night

Sean Casey Bobblehead

G.G. Sabathia Bobblehead

Victor Martinez Bobblehead

Scott Rolen Bobblehead

Danny Graves Wobbler


Framed Detroit Tigers Autographed Dark Green Jersey

Framed Jim Thome Autographed Jersey, Bat, Photograph and game tickets 48" X 42"

Circa 1965 custom made Louisville Child's Baseball Uniform

Autographed Hats:
Cal Ripken Jr. Autographed Hat
Assorted other Hats

Autographed Balls:

Ball signed by Hank Aaron, Frank Robinson, Harmon Killebrew, Mickey Mantle, Reggie Jackson, Ted Williams, Willie McCovey, Eddie Mathews, Ernie Banks, Mel Ott.

Hank Aaron Signed Ball

Matt Williams Signed Ball

Lou Bourdeau Signed Ball

Sandy Alomar Jr. Signed Balls

Jason Bere Signed Ball

Charlie Manual, David Sehge, Travis Fryman signed Ball

Many Signed Balls with Unkown (to auctioneer) Signatures

Autographed Bats:

500 Home Run Club Bat: Hank Aaron, Mickey Mantle Ted Williams, Reggie Jackson Etc.

536 Career Home runs Mickey Mantle Signed 12 of 24

1995 Indians Signed and Carved Heavy Hitter bat #1841 of 1995

Travis Hafner 2006 Signed Bat tied major league record 6 grand slams.

Baseball Cards:

Way too many to list, Please she photos for a sampling. There are cards of all ages, sizes and shapes. Don Russ, Topps, Topps Gold, Upper Deck, Leaf Sets, Studio, Gold Rush, Score, Fleer,  From 30's up. Cracker Jacks, Triple Play, Jersey Cards, 

Other Cards:

Basketball, Football, Boxing, Hockey, Desert Storm, Harley Davidson, Rap Singers, Country Music stars, 

Assorted Curiosities:
 Mark Mcguire Small Wheaties Boxes, Topps Baseball Coins, Joe Morgan Statue,  1997 World Series Commemorative Silver Coins, 2 Indians Proof Sets, 1997 Cleveland Indians Team Banner, Autographed Books, Classic Trivia Games. October 26, 1968 OSU vs Illinois Ticket, Babe Ruth Day 1947 33 1/3 RPM Record.

Missie K. Striker, "Your Friendly Auctioneer"

Becca Hostetler, Apprentice Auctioneer

Mark Twain Frazier  Apprentice Auctioneer

Food service available.

We accept Cash, Check Debit and Credit. 

Real Estate for Sale at Auction


1924 State Route 598, Galion, OH 44833

 Property sells to the highest bidder on auction day, subject to seller confirmation. Property sells as-is with no buyer contingencies for financing, inspections or otherwise. Clean deed at closing with no liens or delinquent taxes. A 10% buyer's premium will be added to the high bid to obtain the final contract selling price. Short pro-ration of taxes. Buyer pays all closing costs. Deposit and Closing: In order to register to bid you must bring a valid state issued ID. The winning bidder will be required to place a deposit in the amount of 10% of the contract sale price at the conclusion of the auction. This will become your non-refundable deposit. Transaction must close on or before Oct. 17, 2019 Realtor Participation: . Please call Auctioneer to schedule all showings. The Seller will review all offers that are presented prior to Auction.

Lot Size: 180 x 180 foot - total of all 3 parcels

Annual Taxes: $ 1080

Ohio Real Estate Auctions - Broker


Basic Terms:

Sells  to the Highest bidder with seller approval. 10% down by cash or check which will become your non refundable deposit. The real estate is sold As Is with no contingencies. All inspections must be done prior to Auction. Close within 30 days. A 10% buyer's premium will be added to the high bid to obtain the final contract selling price. Short tax proration. Buyer pays all closing costs. General warranty deed given at closing with no liens or back taxes.

Realtor Participation:

Realtor showings and cooperation are encouraged.form attachment. Please call Auctioneer to schedule all showings.

Find out more - Ohio Real Estate Auctions Broker Website

Auction on site Sept. 17, 2019 @ 6pm

Lot for Sale 561 Laughbaum Dr. Galion OH


Lot for Sale, Ready to Build


Property Overview - Great building lot! Concrete drive in place. Public water & public sewer available. Bring your site plans and contractor to build your dream home.  



Amanda J. Paez - Real Estate Sales Agent (419) 689-4066

561 Laughbaum Dr. Property Overview - Great building lot! Concrete drive in place. Public water & public sewer available. Bring your site plans and contractor to build your dream home. 


About Us

Missie K. Striker C.A.G.A.


Your Friendly Auctioneer 

Real Estate Sales Agent

Certified Personal Property Appraiser

Ohio Real Estate Auctions


real estate listings

Amanda J. Paez C.A.G.A.



Certified Personal Property Appraiser 

Real Estate Sales Agent 

We are a family operated full service auction and appraisal company with experience in appraising and auctioneering a vast variety of merchandise including full household estates, antiques, jewelry, coins, cars, tractors, equipment and much more.

We pride ourselves in being honest and efficient.  Please consider using our appraisal and auction services in the future.

Complete auction services

  • Real Estate
  • Full service onsite auctions 
  • Consignment auctions  
  • Tag sales
  • Buy outs and  clean outs

Certified personal property appraisal

  • Professional written appraisals
  • Same day report upon request 
  • Available for court room testimony 



Contact Us

Drop us a line!

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Castle Auctions & Appraisals

301 South Sandusky Avenue, Bucyrus, Ohio 44820, United States

(419) 689-0208